Watch the video · Profit lever 5 of 6
Do you need eCommerce accounting, or an eCommerce accountant? Click here to get a quote
The smallest-looking number, and one of the most dangerous
This whole series is about one thing: more profit, without more sales. In the last video we went after your shipping and 3PL costs.
Now we move to the smallest-looking number on the list, and one of the most dangerous. Your refunds.
This video covers profit lever 5: refunds.
1. What the refund profit lever is
A refund is money you give back to a customer after the sale. That sounds simple enough. The problem is what a refund does not give back.
A refund does not undo the sale. It only undoes the money.
- You already paid to ship it out.
- You already paid the warehouse to pick and pack it.
- You paid to get it back, and you paid the warehouse again to handle it.
- Your ad spend is gone.
- And on a lot of platforms, the channel keeps its fee anyway.
So you hand back all of the money, and you keep a large share of the other costs.
When you record refunds correctly, it does two things for you. It shows you what returns are really costing you. And it lets you track changes over time. Every dollar that does not come back improves your contribution.
2. Why it matters so much
It is one of the smallest slices on the table, and that is exactly why nobody watches it.
On a $100 sale, returns might average $5. It looks harmless. Now say your contribution on that sale is $10. If your refund rate creeps up so that the $5 becomes $10, your contribution could halve. A move of five dollars in every hundred took away half of everything you had left. And nothing else changed.
The good news is that refunds are concentrated, so the fixes are small and specific. And they are worth more than they look. On top of the money you give back, a return could cost you around 21% of the order value just to process. For example:
- Finding the few products behind most of your returns. Around 20% of products usually drive 80% of the returns.
- Fewer returns from product pages that match what actually arrives. About one in five returns happen because they do not.
- 30 to 50% fewer returns on products that are hard to use, just from better instructions.
None of those are dramatic on their own. But stack them together and the change in your contribution is significant.
3. Where to find the number
In your financial data. Do not use the returns report in Shopify or Seller Central for this. Those numbers are wrong for this purpose. They count units coming back. They do not carry the cost of getting them back.
You need your income statement, also called the profit and loss statement. And here is the problem you are most likely to hit. A lot of accountants take the refund straight off the revenue figure. They show you one smaller number and call it net sales. So the refund disappears.
And if it is not there, you have a problem
If your refunds are hidden inside revenue, you cannot see your refund rate at all. You cannot fix what you cannot see.
You will not know which channel is driving it. You will not know which products are coming back. And your contribution will be wrong, because the cost of handling those returns is still sitting in your numbers.
4. How to measure it
- Open your accounting software. Xero or QuickBooks. Find the Income Statement, also called the Profit and Loss (P&L).
- Find your refunds line. It may be called refunds or returns. It must sit underneath your sales, as a deduction, on its own line. Not netted into the revenue figure.
- Show each sales channel separately. Amazon. Shopify. Walmart. TikTok Shop. If it is lumped in with something else, you can never pull it apart again.
- Compare 3 to 6 months. Set the report up so it shows at least three to six months side by side.
- Export it to Excel. Then do the calculation below.
What it needs to look like
Illustrative month for one store selling on Shopify and Amazon. Your line names may differ. The layout is what matters.
| Income statement line | Shopify | Amazon |
|---|---|---|
| Gross revenue | $70,000 | $50,000 |
| Shipping income | $3,000 | – |
| Less discounts | -$4,000 | -$1,000 |
| Less refunds | -$3,500 | -$3,000 |
| Net revenue | $65,500 | $46,000 |
| Refund lever | 5.0% | 6.0% |
Two things that belong on your balance sheet, not here
- Store credit. When you give credit instead of cash, that money is sitting in your bank but it is not yours. You owe the customer product. Until they spend it, it is a debt. More in Give Store Credit, Not Cash Back.
- The returned unit itself. If you can sell it again, it goes back into your stock and its product cost comes back out. If it is damaged, the cost stays and the unit gets written off.
Get that wrong and both your profit and your stock figure are wrong.
Then the calculation itself
Create a formula in Excel. Take the refunds for one channel, and divide them by the gross revenue for that same channel. Gross revenue, not net revenue. The refund is one of the things that takes gross down to net, so measuring it against net would be circular. And use that channel, not your whole business.
Refund profit lever
Refunds ÷ Gross revenue
Gross revenue is your sales before anything is taken off. Work it out per channel.
Why track it as a percentage, not dollars?
Your dollar amount goes up and down with your sales volume. So a bigger number might just mean you had a good month. The percentage takes the volume out. It shows you whether the returns themselves are getting worse. A rate that walks from 3% to 4% over six months is not noise. Something changed.
The average hides the losers
Refunds are almost never a whole-business problem. Three or four products usually drive half of everything that comes back. Or one channel does. Or one type of customer. So your overall rate can look perfectly healthy while a handful of products quietly destroy your profit.
Break it down by channel, and by product if you can. Find those few first. Then work out why they come back. The answer is nearly always something in the customer experience, and almost never your returns policy.
5. What to do next
Now you know what your refunds are really costing you, and where they come from. Go to the Refund Plays in the Profit Playbook and pick a play you would like to try. There are five of them. Make the change, give it a month, then run the same exercise to see if the play worked.
And one last thing. Open your own income statement and look for this:
- If there is no refund line at all, ask your accountant to pull it out of revenue and show it separately.
- If it is there but it is one blended number, ask them to split it by sales channel.
- Ask them where your store credit is sitting. It should be a liability on the balance sheet.
If they cannot do that, come and talk to us. That is the part we can fix for you.
6. Quick reference: what to avoid and what to apply
What to avoid
- Letting refunds get netted into a single net sales figure.
- Using platform returns reports to judge what returns cost.
- Booking store credit as income before it is spent.
- Trusting one overall refund rate for the whole business.
- Reaching for a stricter returns policy first.
What to apply
- Show refunds as their own deduction under sales, per channel.
- Divide refunds by gross revenue, not net revenue.
- Keep store credit as a liability on the balance sheet.
- Find the few products and channels behind most returns.
- Fix the customer experience, then measure it after a month.
Can’t find these numbers in your books?
That is the part we can fix for you. CronosNow does accounting and bookkeeping for eCommerce sellers, with every profit lever on its own line and split by sales channel. Or take our free 31-Point Profit Diagnostic and see where your profit is leaking.
Definitions & modeling notes
Definitions
- Contribution
- What is left of a sale after all six variable costs are paid. It pays your fixed costs. Whatever remains after that is profit.
- Refund
- Money given back to a customer after the sale. The shipping, handling, ad and fee costs usually stay with you.
- Store credit
- Credit given instead of cash. A liability on your balance sheet until the customer spends it.
- Gross revenue
- Your sales before anything is taken off.
Modeling notes
- The income statement tables use one illustrative month for a store selling on Shopify (gross revenue $70,000, shipping income $3,000, discounts $4,000, refunds $3,500, net revenue $65,500) and Amazon (gross revenue $50,000, discounts $1,000, refunds $3,000, net revenue $46,000). Percentages are rounded to one decimal place.
- Refund lever: Shopify $3,500 ÷ $70,000 = 5.0%. Amazon $3,000 ÷ $50,000 = 6.0%.
- Halving example: $100 sale, $5 of returns, $10 of contribution. Returns rising to $10 takes contribution to $5, before any extra handling cost.