Watch the video · Profit lever 6 of 6

Do you need eCommerce accounting, or an eCommerce accountant? Click here to get a quote

The cost nobody ever negotiates

This whole series is about one thing: more profit, without more sales. In the last video we went after your refunds.

Now we tackle the cost nobody ever negotiates. Your channel fees and commissions.

This video covers profit lever 6: channel fees.

1. What the channel fee profit lever is

Channel fees are what the platform and the payment provider take out of every sale:

  • Your Shopify fee.
  • Your card processor.
  • PayPal, which is different again.
  • Buy now, pay later, which is higher than both.
  • And on Amazon, the referral fee. That is their commission for the sale.

One thing does not belong here. Amazon’s fulfilment fee is them picking, packing and shipping the box. That is a shipping cost. This line is only about what it costs you to make the sale, not to deliver it. Put them in the same place and your Amazon fees look terrible while your shipping looks cheap. Neither number is usable.

When you record channel fees correctly, it does two things for you. It shows you what each place you sell is really charging you. And it lets you track changes over time. Every dollar you save improves your contribution.

2. Why it matters so much

Most sellers treat these fees as a cost of doing business. Something you just have to accept. They are not. Their impact is relatively small overall, but they are one of the most negotiable costs you have. And the reason nobody negotiates them is simpler than you think. Most sellers have never seen the number.

It is a small slice with a big say in what you keep. On a $100 sale, the fees might be $5. Move to a different provider, or start selling into another country, and that $5 becomes $10. Your contribution just took a nosedive, and nothing about your product, your ads or your customers changed.

The good news is that these savings are structural. Fix it once and it recurs on every order after that. And they are some of the fastest wins in the Playbook. For example:

None of those are dramatic on their own. But stack them together and the change in your contribution is significant.

3. Where to find the number

In your financial data. And here is why this one is harder than the others. When Shopify or Amazon pays you, they do not send you the full amount and bill you later. They take their cut first, and send you what is left.

So a deposit of $42,000 lands in your bank, and your bookkeeper writes down $42,000 of sales. But that was really $44,500 of sales and $2,500 of fees. The fee never appears anywhere. It just went missing.

You need your income statement, also called the profit and loss statement. It has to show the full price the customer paid, and then the fee coming off it. That means your books have to be built from the platform settlement reports, not from your bank feed.

One more thing. When Amazon collects sales tax for you, that money was never yours. It comes in and goes straight back out. It should never touch your sales figure.

And if it is not, you have a problem

If your books only show the money that arrived in your bank, the fee does not exist. You cannot negotiate a fee you cannot see.

Your revenue is understated, your contribution is wrong, and there is nothing there to work on. And on most books, whatever fees are recorded land in one line called bank charges. One line, hiding several different costs, every one of them negotiable.

4. How to measure it

  1. Open your accounting software. Xero or QuickBooks. Find the Income Statement, also called the Profit and Loss (P&L).
  2. Find merchant and channel fees. It needs to be its own section. Not inside bank charges.
  3. Split it two ways. By where you sold it: Amazon, Shopify, Walmart, TikTok Shop. And by provider within each channel. If it is lumped in with something else, you can never pull it apart again.
  4. Compare 3 to 6 months. Set the report up so it shows at least three to six months side by side.
  5. Export it to Excel. Then do the calculation below.

What it needs to look like

Illustrative month for one store selling on Shopify and Amazon. Your line names may differ. The layout is what matters.

Income statement lineShopifyAmazon
Shopify Payments (card fees)-$1,900–
PayPal-$450–
Buy now, pay later-$600–
Amazon referral fees–-$7,000
Total channel and payment fees-$2,950-$7,000
Net revenue$65,500$46,000
Channel fee lever4.5%15.2%

Then the calculation itself

Create a formula in Excel. Take the channel fees for one channel, and divide them by the net revenue for that same channel. That channel, not your whole business.

Channel fee profit lever

Channel fees and commissions ÷ Net revenue

Net revenue = Gross revenue + Shipping income - Discounts - Refunds. Work it out per channel.

Why track it as a percentage, not dollars?

Your dollar amount goes up and down with your sales volume. So a bigger number might just mean you had a good month. The percentage takes the volume out. It tells you what your provider really charged you across a whole month.

5. What to do next

Now you know what each place you sell is actually charging you. Go to the Channel Fee Plays in the Profit Playbook and pick a play you would like to try. Make the change, give it a month or so, then run the same exercise to see if the play worked.

And one last thing. Open your own income statement and look for this:

  • If your sales figure matches what landed in your bank, your fees are missing. Ask your accountant to record the full sale and the fee separately.
  • If the fees are sitting in bank charges, ask them to give them their own line, split by channel and by provider.
  • If your Amazon fulfilment fees are in there, ask them to move those out. They belong with your shipping.

If they cannot do that, come and talk to us. That is the part we can fix for you.

6. Quick reference: what to avoid and what to apply

What to avoid

  • Recording sales from your bank deposits instead of settlement reports.
  • Leaving channel and payment fees inside bank charges.
  • Keeping Amazon fulfilment fees with Amazon seller fees.
  • Letting marketplace sales tax touch your sales figure.
  • Accepting fees as a fixed cost of doing business.

What to apply

  • Build your books from platform settlement reports.
  • Show the full sale, then the fee, on separate lines.
  • Split fees by sales channel and by provider.
  • Divide channel fees by net revenue, per channel.
  • Test one channel fee play, then measure it after a month.

Can’t find these numbers in your books?

That is the part we can fix for you. CronosNow does accounting and bookkeeping for eCommerce sellers, with every profit lever on its own line and split by sales channel. Or take our free 31-Point Profit Diagnostic and see where your profit is leaking.

Get a Quote Take the free Profit Diagnostic

Definitions & modeling notes

Definitions

Contribution
What is left of a sale after all six variable costs are paid. It pays your fixed costs. Whatever remains after that is profit.
Channel fees
What the platform and payment provider take from each sale: platform fees, card processing, PayPal, buy now pay later, and marketplace referral fees.
Referral fee
Amazon’s commission on each sale. Separate from its fulfilment (FBA) fee, which is a shipping cost.
Settlement report
The platform’s statement of each payout, showing the full sales and every fee taken before the deposit.
Net revenue
Gross revenue plus shipping income, minus discounts and refunds.

Modeling notes

  • The income statement tables use one illustrative month for a store selling on Shopify (gross revenue $70,000, shipping income $3,000, discounts $4,000, refunds $3,500, net revenue $65,500) and Amazon (gross revenue $50,000, discounts $1,000, refunds $3,000, net revenue $46,000). Percentages are rounded to one decimal place.
  • Channel fee lever: Shopify $2,950 ÷ $65,500 = 4.5%. Amazon $7,000 ÷ $46,000 = 15.2%. Amazon FBA fees sit with shipping, not here.
  • Deposit example: $44,500 of sales - $2,500 of fees = $42,000 deposited.