Watch the video · Profit lever 2 of 6

Do you need eCommerce accounting, or an eCommerce accountant? Click here to get a quote

The second biggest variable cost

The Profit Playbook series is all about making more profit, without more sales. In the last video we worked on the product cost lever: how to measure your product cost correctly, and why it matters.

Now we move to the second biggest variable cost in most ecommerce businesses. Your ad spend.

This video covers profit lever 2: direct ad spend.

1. What the direct ad spend profit lever is

For our purposes, direct ad spend is the money you paid to put an ad in front of someone to get a sale. That includes Meta, Google, TikTok or any other digital advertising that can be traced back to a sale. Yes, even an influencer you paid to promote your product counts. As long as you can trace it to a sale, it belongs on this line.

So what is not included?

Costs that do not move with each sale. Marketing software, marketing material, photo shoots and web design are not included. Those are fixed costs. They do not move when your sales move, so they sit further down your income statement with things like rent and salaries.

What about brand and affiliate campaigns?

Those do have an impact on your overall marketing. But they usually cannot be traced back to a specific sale. They are still advertising, so they stay in the advertising section of your books. They just get their own group, separate from the direct spend.

The reason is simple. One kind of ad chases a sale today. The other builds trust for later. Mix them together and both look wrong. Your direct ads look worse than they are, and your brand spend never gets the credit it deserves. We cover this in Judge Your Two Kinds of Ads Apart.

When you record direct ad spend correctly, it does two things for you. It shows you what it really costs to buy a sale. And it lets you track changes over time. Every dollar you save improves your contribution.

2. Why it matters so much

In most ecommerce businesses, ads are the second biggest variable cost. The goal here is not to cut the budget. It is to make your ads more effective: find the products and campaigns that cost you ad dollars without making you a profit.

The good news is that the waste is usually bigger than people think. Brands that start measuring their ads on real profit, instead of the dashboard, have been known to cut 15 to 30% of their ad spend without losing revenue. The two things you want to achieve:

Say ad spend is 20% of your $100,000 a month in net revenue. You find 10% of it going to campaigns that do not perform, switch them off, and move that money to winning campaigns. If the new campaign is genuinely better, it brings in more revenue for the same money. Your ad spend in dollars has not changed. But your net revenue is higher, so the ad spend percentage goes down.

That is the whole game

You are not trying to spend less on ads. You are trying to get more revenue out of the same ad dollar.

And there is a simple check on this. Ad spend as a percentage of net revenue is just your return on ad spend turned upside down. If your real return goes up, that percentage has to come down. It is the same number read from the other end. So if you move the money and the percentage does not budge, the new campaign was not better. It was just different.

Now what if you want to spend more?

Say your ad spend is $1,000 and your net revenue is $4,000. That is 25%. You double the ad spend to $2,000, the campaigns hold up, and revenue doubles to $8,000. You are still at 25%. The percentage did not move. But your contribution doubled.

That is the point of this number. It is not telling you to spend less. It is telling you whether your advertising is still working as well as it was.

  • Flat while you grow is a win.
  • Down while you grow is a bigger win.
  • Up is the warning.

3. Where to find the number

In your financial data. Do not use your Meta, Google or Amazon ads manager dashboards for this. Those numbers are wrong for this purpose. They cannot see your net revenue. They do not know your shipping income, your discounts or your refunds. They do not know what your product costs you either. So the return on ad spend they show you is just sales divided by ad spend. It can look brilliant while every order is losing you money.

You need your income statement, also called the profit and loss statement. Your data should trace back to the real invoices from the ad platforms, captured properly in your books. And it must sit in the month the ads ran, not the month your bank paid for them. Ad platforms sometimes bill you 30 to 60 days late. If your books record ads when the money leaves your bank, every month is wrong.

And if it is not, you have a problem

If your ad spend is wrong, your contribution is wrong. If that number ever goes negative, you will not know you are losing money on every sale.

4. How to measure it

  1. Open your accounting software. Xero or QuickBooks. Find the Income Statement, also called the Profit and Loss (P&L).
  2. Find your advertising line. It may be called advertising, marketing or ad spend. You want the total for the period, on its own line. If it is lumped in with something else, you can never pull it apart again.
  3. Show each sales channel separately, then split by platform. Amazon Ads under Amazon. Meta, Google and Bing under Shopify. With a total for each channel.
  4. Compare 3 to 6 months. Set the report up so it shows at least three to six months side by side.
  5. Export it to Excel. Then do the calculation below.

What it needs to look like

Illustrative month for one store selling on Shopify and Amazon. Your line names may differ. The layout is what matters.

Income statement lineShopifyAmazon
Meta Ads-$8,000–
Google Ads-$4,500–
Bing Ads-$600–
Amazon Ads–-$5,600
Total direct ad spend-$13,100-$5,600
Brand and affiliate (own group, not in this lever)-$2,000–
Net revenue$65,500$46,000
Direct ad spend lever20.0%12.2%

Then the calculation itself

Create a formula in Excel. Take the direct ad spend for one channel, and divide it by the net revenue for that same channel. That channel, not your whole business. The ads you ran on Amazon have nothing to do with the revenue you made on Shopify. With one blended advertising number, you would never see which channel is the problem.

Direct ad spend profit lever

Direct ad spend ÷ Net revenue

Net revenue = Gross revenue + Shipping income - Discounts - Refunds. Work it out per channel.

Why track it as a percentage, not dollars?

Your dollar amount goes up and down with your sales volume. So a bigger number might just mean you had a good month. The percentage takes the volume out. It shows you whether the ads themselves actually got more expensive.

One thing this does not measure

Everything above measures one thing: whether your ad spend is getting more efficient over time, or less. That is not your return on ad spend. A real return on ad spend takes off the product cost first, and the shipping, the fees and the refunds. That is what tells you whether the sale was worth making at all. The Profit Playbook has a dedicated section on it, and you can start with See If Your Ads Really Make Money.

The two fit together. This lever tells you whether your advertising is getting more expensive. Contribution tells you whether the sale paid for itself.

5. What to do next

Go to the Direct Ad Spend Plays in the Profit Playbook and pick a play you would like to try. Make the change, give it a month, then run the same exercise to see if the play worked.

And one last thing. Open your own income statement and look for this:

  • If your ad spend is one blended number, with no Meta, Google or Amazon Ads lines under the right channel, ask your accountant to split it by sales channel.
  • If your influencer and brand spend is sitting in with your direct campaigns, ask them to give it its own group.

If they cannot do that, come and talk to us. That is the part we can fix for you.

6. Quick reference: what to avoid and what to apply

What to avoid

  • Using ads manager dashboards to judge whether ads make money.
  • Recording ads in the month you paid, not the month they ran.
  • Mixing brand and affiliate spend in with direct campaigns.
  • Keeping one blended ad spend number for the whole business.
  • Treating a lower ad budget as the goal.

What to apply

  • Put every direct ad platform on its own line, under its sales channel.
  • Give brand and affiliate spend its own group in advertising.
  • Divide direct ad spend by net revenue, per channel.
  • Aim for a flat or falling percentage as you grow.
  • Move money from losing campaigns to proven winners.

Can’t find these numbers in your books?

That is the part we can fix for you. CronosNow does accounting and bookkeeping for eCommerce sellers, with every profit lever on its own line and split by sales channel. Or take our free 31-Point Profit Diagnostic and see where your profit is leaking.

Get a Quote Take the free Profit Diagnostic

Definitions & modeling notes

Definitions

Contribution
What is left of a sale after all six variable costs are paid. It pays your fixed costs. Whatever remains after that is profit.
Direct ad spend
Money paid to put an ad in front of someone to get a sale, that can be traced back to the sale. Includes paid influencers.
Brand and affiliate spend
Advertising that builds trust for later and usually cannot be traced to a specific sale. Kept in its own group.
Return on ad spend (ROAS)
Sales divided by ad spend. A real ROAS takes product cost, shipping, fees and refunds off first.
Net revenue
Gross revenue plus shipping income, minus discounts and refunds.

Modeling notes

  • The income statement tables use one illustrative month for a store selling on Shopify (gross revenue $70,000, shipping income $3,000, discounts $4,000, refunds $3,500, net revenue $65,500) and Amazon (gross revenue $50,000, discounts $1,000, refunds $3,000, net revenue $46,000). Percentages are rounded to one decimal place.
  • Direct ad spend lever: Shopify $13,100 ÷ $65,500 = 20.0%. Amazon $5,600 ÷ $46,000 = 12.2%. The $2,000 brand and affiliate group is excluded.
  • Scaling example: $1,000 ÷ $4,000 = 25%; $2,000 ÷ $8,000 = 25%.