Watch the video · Start here: the Profit Playbook video series
Do you need eCommerce accounting, or an eCommerce accountant? Click here to get a quote
The one number most sellers cannot tell you
Everything in this series comes back to one idea: getting more profit, without more sales.
And in ecommerce there is one number that matters more than the rest. Most sellers cannot tell you what it is. They might tell you it is their revenue. Or their gross profit. Or their return on ad spend.
Here is the core problem. None of those numbers tell you whether you actually made money on the sale. The number you are looking for is called contribution.
1. What contribution is
Contribution is what is left over after your variable costs have been taken off the sale.
So what are variable costs? They are simply costs that go up when you make more sales. Every time you sell a product, you pay to ship it to the customer. That is a variable cost. Every time you make a sale, you pay payment processing fees. That is a variable cost too. Unlike rent or salaries, the cost is tied directly to the sale.
In ecommerce there are six variable costs that really matter.
2. The six costs behind it
Imagine you sell a product for $100. Your variable costs could look like the table below.
So the customer paid you $100, and you kept $10. That $10 is your contribution. The other six slices are your variable costs.
Now notice something about that list. Those six costs are the six profit levers we cover in the Profit Playbook. They are the same thing. And when you understand how to improve them, you can unlock profit you never knew was there.
Where $100 of sales goes
One sale at $100. The colors match the pie in the video.
| Profit lever | Value |
|---|---|
| Product cost (Cost of Goods Sold) | -$40 |
| Ads | -$20 |
| Discount (to get them over the line) | -$10 |
| 3PL and shipping | -$10 |
| Payment fees | -$5 |
| Returns | -$5 |
| Contribution | +$10 |
Before we go further, one thing to be clear on
Contribution is not your profit, and it is not the cash in your bank. It is the money each sale hands you to pay your fixed costs with.
Contribution only deals with the variable costs. Whatever is left after you pay your fixed costs is your profit.
3. Why it matters so much
Contribution is the single most important number in your ecommerce business.
If you do not know what your contribution is, you cannot see it when it goes negative. And if you cannot see that, you will not know when you start losing money.
I can tell you from experience, there are sellers scaling stores where every order loses them money. To them it looks like growth, because the sales keep climbing. But all they are doing is losing money faster.
And your P&L will not warn you either. Many accountants never break these six costs out in detail. They often get lumped into one number. For example, the revenue you see in your income statement often shows the net amount after discounts and refunds. Because you never see them on their own, you do not track them.
4. Three things to do about it
- Get all six variable costs onto your P&L. You want all six of them visible. Each on its own line, under the channel they came from. If you sell on Amazon and Shopify, for example, you should see these six costs for each channel. Do not let anyone bury them inside one big cost line. If they are hidden, you cannot work on them. And then you have no levers to pull.
- Work out your contribution per sales channel and per order. Do this per channel, because different channels have different cost structures. Amazon and Shopify differ widely. Take the sale price and take off the six costs. What is left is your contribution in dollars. Then divide that by the sale price. That is your contribution margin. We find it useful to work with a three to six month average.
- Never look at the average on its own. Your overall contribution can look healthy while half your products lose money on every order. The average hides the losers. So if you can, also break it down by product. This can be the most time-consuming step, but it is also the one that gives the most insight.
Contribution margin
Contribution ÷ Sale price
Contribution is the sale price minus the six variable costs. You need both numbers. The dollars tell you what one order gives you. The percentage tells you whether it is getting better or worse.
Contribution per sales channel
Illustrative month for one store selling on Shopify and Amazon. Your line names may differ. The layout is what matters.
| Income statement line | Shopify | Amazon |
|---|---|---|
| Sales (gross revenue plus shipping income) | $73,000 | $50,000 |
| Discounts | -$4,000 | -$1,000 |
| Refunds | -$3,500 | -$3,000 |
| Product cost (landed COGS) | -$26,200 | -$19,200 |
| Direct ad spend | -$13,100 | -$5,600 |
| Outbound shipping and 3PL | -$10,100 | -$7,600 |
| Channel and payment fees | -$2,950 | -$7,000 |
| Contribution | $13,150 | $6,600 |
| Contribution margin | 18.0% | 13.2% |
Same store, two very different channels. Blend them into one number and you would never see that Amazon keeps less of every dollar.
In conclusion
Contribution is what you keep once everything that came with the sale has been paid for. Get the six costs onto the page. Work out the number. Then watch it every month. Once you can see it, you can improve it. That is what the six profit levers are for.
Start with whichever lever is costing you the most. Test one Profit Play. Then measure it. Because if you do not measure it, you will never know if it worked. For a worked example of all six costs on one sale, read Know Your Numbers Before You Run a Sale.
5. Quick reference: what to avoid and what to apply
What to avoid
- Judging your business on revenue, gross profit or return on ad spend alone.
- Letting your six variable costs sit inside one big cost line.
- Reading revenue that already has discounts and refunds netted out.
- Trusting one blended average across every channel and product.
- Mistaking contribution for profit or for cash in the bank.
What to apply
- Put all six variable costs on their own lines, under each sales channel.
- Work out contribution in dollars and as a margin, per channel.
- Use a three to six month average, then watch it every month.
- Break contribution down by product to find the losers.
- Pull one lever at a time, test one play, and measure it.
Want your six costs mapped for you?
Our free 31-Point Profit Diagnostic puts a dollar figure on where your profit is leaking. Or get a quote for done-for-you eCommerce accounting, with all six costs on their own lines.
Definitions & modeling notes
Definitions
- Contribution
- What is left of a sale after all six variable costs are paid. It pays your fixed costs. Whatever remains after that is profit.
- Variable cost
- A cost that goes up when you make more sales, like shipping or payment fees.
- Fixed cost
- A cost that stays the same whatever you sell, like rent, salaries and software.
- Contribution margin
- Contribution divided by the sale price.
- The six profit levers
- (1) Discounts, (2) Refunds, (3) Product cost (landed COGS), (4) Sales channel and payment fees, (5) Shipping and 3PL fees, (6) Advertising spend.
Modeling notes
- The $100 example uses the series’ teaching numbers: product cost $40, ads $20, discount $10, 3PL and shipping $10, payment fees $5, returns $5, leaving $10 of contribution.
- The income statement tables use one illustrative month for a store selling on Shopify (gross revenue $70,000, shipping income $3,000, discounts $4,000, refunds $3,500, net revenue $65,500) and Amazon (gross revenue $50,000, discounts $1,000, refunds $3,000, net revenue $46,000). Percentages are rounded to one decimal place. Shopify: $73,000 - $4,000 - $3,500 - $26,200 - $13,100 - $10,100 - $2,950 = $13,150. Amazon: $50,000 - $1,000 - $3,000 - $19,200 - $5,600 - $7,600 - $7,000 = $6,600.